FicWad

Categories > Books > Harry Potter > An American Wizard in Hogwarts

Reviews

• An American Wizard in Hogwarts

  (#) Cateagle 2008-07-02

  Regarding the disclaimer, if a rooster lays an egg, I'm going to be exceedingly surprised (as, I imagine, would he). I like the prophecies and they work well. 'Twould appear that Lucy is the White Witch and I'd hazard a guess that Ron is the Traitor; I'm not sure, yet, who's the Jester (Neville, perhaps? But it doesn't seem to suit what we know of him).

  Author's response

  Maybe...The Jester will be a canon character, used in a relatively canon way, perhaps with a few embellishments. The Traitor will be a canon character handled in a slightly non-canon way. I give a big clue about the identities of the Jester and the Traitor, but so far no one has picked up on them. I don't plan on revealing who for a while, unfortunately for you.

• An American Wizard in Hogwarts

  (#) minerdude 2008-07-02

  White witch-- Ginny or Lucy
  Jester-- Ron
  Traitor-- I guessing Snape or Draco

• An American Wizard in Hogwarts

  (#) pstibbons 2008-07-16

  If Ron's a traitor, hasn't Matt spotted it already?
  
  The narration from Matt's POV really is working quite well.

  Author's response

  Finally, someone picked up on that.
  
  I didn't want to say this so soon, since I am not going to reveal the Traitor and Jester until later, but Ron is most definitely NOT the traitor.

Sign up to review this story.